Burghound.com/Allen Meadows 89/100: "Picard makes the only example of Chaumées in red. Here the nose is slightly more elegant with good breadth that is supplied by pure and ripe notes of red berries, pungent earth and soft floral hints where a touch of menthol can also be discerned. There is a seductive texture to the delicious medium-bodied flavors that are underpinned by relatively fine-grained tannins before terminating in a reasonably persistent and balanced finish. Once again this is built to enjoy young"

Jancis Robinson 17+/20: "A little less purple than the Concis des Champs. Crushed plum skins and cracked coriander seeds - a more earthy nose than his Concis des Champs and his Saint-Aubin Le Charmois. This whole wine seems more earthbound: more holding back, more autumn hedgerow than late-summer fruit. There's a tension to the tannins that very gently pushes you back and holds you on the outer edge. Herbal. Wait a bit, but this has a lot to offer. Drink 2018-2025"